According to Remy the reason Hayhurst is such an ******* is because he only presented the information he wanted to present.
I knew Buch whipped off a lot. In fact I have seen him go to his mouth more than once between pitches and wipe off every time after going to his mouth. Remy says he went back and looked at every pitch from that game and reports that Buch whipped off every time before throwing every pitch.
As for what Hayhurst was claiming...I really don't know. Although he did say the words.....He did describe it as loading up the baseball. I have always used that term to describe the spit ball, the Gaylord Perry and others...spitter. That sort of pitch is almost unhittable and sometimes is unhittable.
So if Hayhurst is accusing Buch of doing something to get a better grip and has decided to use the term loading the baseball to do it that is sorta' sucky. I think the whole thing is ******** because Hayhurst is only presenting the information he wants to present and he is presenting it in a way that is frankly less than accurate, disingenuous and designed to be purposefully provocative.
As for trying to get a better grip which I for one have never described as "loading the baseball", all pitchers try things to get a better grip. If Buch is using a combination of rosin and water, I don't see what Hayhurst is complaining about, especially since Buch whips off before every pitch.