You had every reason to have a heart attack when the guy even got up to stretch his legs, for fear he may actually come in. I think Papelbon is done, myself. That's why the Fuentes signing will be so nice. Fuentes, Bard, and Jenks can all close out games instead of Pap if he struggles or if he needs a night or two off.
Of all relief pitchers with at least 20 saves last year (29 pitchers), Papelbon was tied for 1st with Francisco Cordero with 8 Blown Saves, he had the 5th worst ERA, and he had the most losses.
He blew 8 saves and converted 37, so he had a 82.23% conversion rate. That's right at the bottom next to Leo Nunez of the qualified closers by the parameters set above (20 saves or more).
I know you're not defending him at all, but the guy was just absolutely awful last year, and I really think people who are thinking he's going to bounce back this year just because it's his contract year don't have too much to lean on.
I'm pretty sure Teixera and A-Rod aren't going to care that it's his contract year when they're up in the bottom of the 9th in a 1 run game.
By the way, more 2010 stats to make you worry
Pap vs BAL - 5.19 ERA
Pap vs NYY - 6.97 ERA
Pap vs TOR - 4.26 ERA
I mean....that's our division right there outside of TB. That's who you have to be good against.
Papelbon?