1. Some scouts have evaluated Cecchini as talent that is as good as, or better than WMB. Also, Xander Bogaerts, who has HanRam type power and potential, is likely going to be moved to 3B because of his size, so if we dealt WMB, it wouldn't be like we're dealing out of a position of no depth. And this isn't even mentioning Kolbrin Vitek, a 1st rounder in 2010 who also plays 3B.
2. Yeah, he's got major offensive potential. But if you want a high caliber pitcher like Garza, you can't give up .200 hitting catchers.
3. Ranaudo has actually lose significant velocity, and was sitting 89-90 all last season. His inconsistency is maddening to a lot of scouts, and he is not pitching as advertised. A lot of scouts are beginning to project him as a relief pitcher.
4. Bogaerts should not be dealt, I agree with this.
Realize this. Garza would be the Sox #2 or #3. If a pitcher of that caliber becomes available, you explore options, which is what I was doing. If we traded for Garza and won the WS in 2012, you wouldn't say anything about the prospects we lost.
It's all about winning.