You're judging the drafts based on players that have barely had their cup of coffee, or are no longer in the system. 2006 had Bard, Masterson, Reddick, Kalish. 2007 had Haggadone, Middlebrooks, Rizzo, Britton. 2008 had Kelly, Westmoreland, Lavarnway. They've gotten plenty of talent despite having late first rounders, it just hasn't turned into players for a variety of reasons.