Well, they made their first mistake in their sudden resurgence--DFAd McDonald. This was a stupid decision, created by their fetish for one reliever an inning. Now they want 12 pitchers! A starter goes 6 innings and 100+ pitches. Then bring on the crappy bullpen loaded with 50 cent relievers.
Was it Buchholz who went 6 innings, threw 108 pitches and was taken out with a 6-1 lead yesterday? That sucks. The guy should have pitched the 7th inning. He was cruising. Any starter worth his salt should be able to go 120 pitches.
So now they lose McDonald for a crappy reliever. A guy who has had some big hits and played a decent CF. Certainly a better ballplayer than Bill Hall. And then you have Ellsbury, Cameron and Drew--all of whom are prone to injuries, or just coming off injuries.
A dumb move they will probably regret. If you took Youks and Pedroia away, this team would collapse like a house of cards.