Duran plays one and sits one vs the LHP in CIN.
I also think the order will change over time. Duran was the leadoff initially last season, before moving down later on. I think we'll see some adjustments after the first month or two.
IDK about Marcus Phillips. His risk as a reliever doesn't seem really big 4 to me.
I like Valera as well, but he didn't really put it all together last season either.
My big four:
Witherspoon, Gonzales, Eyanson, Godbout
He earned $45M in '24 and '25 because of his season in '23. Not sure he was going to get anything this year. Maybe he could have received a larger offer if he signed earlier in the offseason that year, but we don't really know for sure. If you looked at his track record, all the teams that didn't want to pay him a large contract were correct.