Rob Refsnyder is a very bad defensive outfielder. Tapia's defense took a hit last year when put in CF and RF, but was still better than Refsnyder's.
Tapia: -4 DRS in 935 innings
Refsnyder: -5 DRS in 303 innings (would be ghastly if pushed to 900 innings)
The projections are kinder to Refsnyder, but I think they heavily weigh his 2022 season. Refsnyder is definitely overrated by a lot of people on here. Tapia could be better than Refsnyder this year, but only if Refsnyder's offense bottoms out again (which isn't entirely unlikely). If he is better, it probably won't be by very much. Both guys are just 4th/5th OFer types.