I don't know...
CC: 3.55 ERA, 1.09 WHIP 78Ks/109 IP
Beckett:3.48 ERA 1.23 WHJP 94Ks/98 IP
I don't know...I'd basically call that a wash.
By the way...it's Fire Cashman, not Girardi. I actually like Girardi and thinks he does a decent job. He's finally gotten the pitchers in their roles, and he's burned out some of the garbage [Veras, Ramirez, Tomko] and found some reliable arms [Hughes, Aceves, Coke].
The emergence of Hughes [pleasant surprise so far, emphasis on "so far"] and the steadiness he's found in Coke and Aceves, this pen is rounding out to be one of the better pens in the game when coupled with Bruney and Mariano...which is pretty much what I thought all along.
People kill Girardi, and although I don't know what goes on behind the scenes, the Yankees are no longer playing station-station baseball, and they're not losing a reliever a season to arm troubles like they did under Torre. We'll see I guess.