I'm talking about drafting.
The reason being is that the Yankees will always do well in the free agent market, especially in Latin America. The Yankees are the most branded product, and they have the most money. We're playing with a stacked deck.
In the draft...well, since we are a good team, we will always be at the bottom of the draft order. However, with our money, it would allow us to sign players that would normally not be available to us because of how they would price themselves. Case in point: Jeter. Jeter fell to the Yankees because of his contract demands and desire to play for the Yankees. A more recent example is Andrew Brackman.
For this reason, I think the draft is a huge indicator of the Front Office efficiency. Any fool can go spend a half a billion and get 3 superstar players.
However, looking at the Red Sox, who have [to the best of my knowledge] drafted Pedroia, Youkilis, Lester, Buchholz...and looking at who the Yankees have drafted in a similar spot...well, hats off to you guys.
You guys have showed you can compete without money. We haven't. That's the truth.
Going back to Joba...the guy should have been given the chance. Here is the logic...Hughes would have been limited. You could have used as a 3 inning a stint guy. Forget the stupid 8th inning role. Just stretch him out as the season went along. First month, 1 inning stint...2nd month, 2 inning stint...third month, 3 inning stints, and stay with that. Next year, phase him in to the rotation.
If Joba did well...well then, great. If he bombed, and it would really take about 2 months to see it, then you could throw Hughes in there and he would be at his limit at the end of the year because he would have been rarely used [innings-wise] for two months. What the Yankees did was guarantee another debacle with their 5th starter for the 2nd season.
Of course...this is said with the disclaimer that he has the endurance to go 7 innings. If they really feel that his shoulder can't hold up, then throw this right out of the window.