Andujar presents an intriguing case. The Yanks currently have tremendous depth. With Tulo in the fold, it adds to it. Once Didi is healthy, it will be far better. If we add Machado, it will be insane. Most people look at Stanton as a minus defender, but he isn't. He had a UZR/150 of 8.2 in RF for the Marlins in 2017 and was very positive in a SSS in 2018 in the OF for NY based on UZR/150. Our best defensive alignment has Gardner in LF, Judge in RF and Stanton at DH. But with Gardner really struggling last season with the bat, if we needed the DH spot, moving Stanton to LF and benching Gardner isn't a big issue. So that would free up DH for Andujar if need be. Also, one must consider the 1b spot. While Bird has promise littered with injury, Voit actually had production last year in a short sample size. If Luke comes out and kills the ball in 2019, then we have a great problem. If he doesn't and hits like Shane Spencer year 2, then we can move Andujar across the diamond to 1b.
Either way, Tulo is a free lottery ticket. He's paid league minimum and is manning a position of need right now. Didi is expected back in May at the earliest, probably more like June. So he will get two months to prove himself barring other additions. If we bring in Machado, then it will push Tulo to play well in ST and earn a spot. He hasn't had to earn anything in over a decade, so he will either sink or swim. My bet is he sinks, but I am clearly open to the possibility that he does well. Now, the dream scenario for the Yanks is Tulo returns to prime level, Machado comes in and kills it, Voit proves he isn't a flash in the pan, and then Didi returns. What a wonderful problem that would be, and it would probably precipitate a trade of some sort. But with the injury histories of Tulo and Bird and the SSS of Voit, there is a strong chance the above doesn't happen