DiceK finished last yrs regular season walking 42 in his last 85 innings. He starts ST with 5BB in 12IP and then 5BB in 5IP. I have never said anything badly about his stuff. I continue to think that his stuff, when he is on is in the top 10% of starting MLB pitchers. But his inconsistency has only worsened since the All Star break. He has shown nothing to prove that he is reverting to his pre-AS break form. If he does, he is at least a #2. If he doesnt, his stuff will be enough to make him a solid back end pitcher, but he'll continue to be erratic.
Lester has been someone I have admired for his cancer battle, but I have questioned his baseball ability from day 1. While I think Buchholz is the real deal, Lester never fit the billing. Nice curveball, but overbilled fastball. A cutter that is average at best and location of all of the above that is terrible. He consistently falls behind hitters and has survived off luck for his MLB career. I dont typically use that argument, but how else can you explain how he parlays a 1.57WHIP into only a 4.68 career ERA. He has thrown 144IP, allowing 152H and 74BB. With those numbers, poor location and mediocre stuff, he either has to locate better, or he will eventually start getting tattooed. Today was just the first example against a team that is terrible. The A's offense is loaded with players who dont belong in the bigs. How is this guy going to fare against the Detroits, New Yorks, Torontos, White Sox of the world?