What happened? Well, I'll tell you what happened.
Phil Hughes and Ian Kennedy proved that they werent ready. Phil physically, Ian mentally. Both should finish the yr in Scranton and both should start next yr there as well. Looks like a lost yr for Phil, while Kennedy is learning the ropes in AAA, a level he never should have skipped.
Igawa has just been plain awful.
Our ace, Wang goes down for 10 weeks, which equates to about 14 starts.
Joba steps in and pitches well.
Mussina and Pettitte show they are still good
Rasner pitches in with #5 starter performance.
Ponson pitches in with #5 starter performance
Alan Horne goes down with an elbow twinge then a tired shoulder, looks like a lost yr for the next yankee arm
Chase Wright, on the 40 man and pitching well early on, goes down with an arm injury, misses a month and comes back very hittable. Lost yr for him
Jeff Karstens injures his leg in ST and comes back as a mediocre AAAA player. Another lost yr
Humberto Sanchez needs surgery to remove bone chips from his elbow in February, knocking him out until May and now he is in the GCL pitching out of the pen. Lost yr and lost rotation option.
Steven White starts the yr on the 40 man and in the rotation, loses all control, gets moved to the pen, is AWFUL, gets put on waivers with no takers and is now stinking up the joint out of Scranton's pen. Lost everything for him.
Alfredo Aceves gets signed out of the Mexican league, dominates AA and A+ ball. Somewhere between his last AA game and his first AAA game he strains his groin and is now working out of the pen
Dan McCutchen lights up AA, struggles initially in AAA and then dominates again. A good option if he was a long term fix, but a poor option for the short term as he has proven time and time again that he struggles right after a callup.
So in all, we had a lot of depth and anything that could go wrong, did. Nobody is hurt to where their careers are in jeopardy, so thats good, but lots of lost yrs for guys who needed to develop.