I am okay with Pettitte coming back under the following conditions.
The medicals work out. IE, a physical, another MRI, etc. His uncharacteristic explosion post ASB has me concerned about an injury. But if they are certain that is not the case, then sign him.
And Pettitte cannot go into the yr in our top 3. We have seen the sox and the rays pass us by in the division mostly based upon the strength of their rotation and the fact that their guys took the bump a lot more than ours did. We need to have 4 reliable starters while leaving that 5 slot to Joba or Hughes. If we resign Moose and Pettitte on 1 yr deals, then I am perfectly fine with one more signing. And maybe it isnt CC, and that's okay. But we cannot afford to go into the yr with Wang, Moose, Pettitte and then having the last 2 slots settled by rooks. It just cannot happen for a second yr in a row