prior to 07, you are right. But 07-08 he has shown a significant dropoff in power and patience making him less desireable. Consider this, in his last 3 full yrs in Philly, his IsoPatience was .119, .127, .109. FOr 07 and 08, his IsoPatience was .086 and .079. His last 3 full yrs in Philly, his IsoPower was .168, .243, and .188. In NY for 07 and 08, .162 and .175. His 2 OPS's in NY for 07 and 08 of .814 and .842 were the 2 lowest totals of his entire career. Abreu was a great addition to this team and I loved what he did for us out of the 3 hole. But he was not the same player in NY as he was in Philly. If he was, we wouldnt have let him walk for nothing.
Nady, OTOH, put up an .867 OPS last yr. And while most of that was due to a power surge, he did out slug and out OPS Abreu. And Swisher, who comes off an abysmal 2008 in CWS, consistently showed the power and patience of his time in Oakland. His BABIP was much lower than it should have been (.249) and potentially points to an unlucky season. When he is on, Swisher is a .120 IsoPatience guy and a .200 IsoPower guy. I think we'll be able to replace him.