I agree with a lot of your post a700. I know a poster on here commented on the pitching and defense moves in 2004 to win a championship, but the lineup was deadly too. You had Ortiz and Manny hitting at elite levels and a lineup without holes, which allowed the sox to move Nomar for OCab and Mientkiewicz.
The sox lineup was built as a funnel. You get a bunch of guys on base and funnel them to the middle of the order where Manny and Ortiz would bring them home. Now, with Manny gone and Ortiz a shell of himself, you need to replace those guys. Bay and Youks did a pretty good job of that last yr. But with Bay gone, you now have a middle of the order with one scary hitter, one good hitter, and one past his prime hitter. That isnt good enough, especially since you have a 6-9 that isnt very good either.
The defense argument, I brought up earlier in the offseason. How do you build a team for pitching and defense when your catcher is one of the worst in the game and you have an average at best SS? You build a defense up the middle and if 2 of the 4 players up the middle are average to well below average, then you wont have an elite defense.
As for the pitching, things will turn around when Lester starts putting up his customary 7IP 2ER performances and Beckett gets more consistent, but I also agree on the middle relief. You have a closer whose effectiveness has been waning since 2007 and a middle relief corps that has been mediocre at best since the ASB last yr. Subtract from that team Wagner and Saito and add in Schoeneweis and Atchison and you see the problem.
Overall, a700, I do think this is Theo's worst job since coming to Boston. But, with the starting pitching, they should win 90 games or so. But, this team really isnt deep enough to win in the playoffs, IMO. They may pitch well, but they wont hit well enough against good pitching