I know the recent skid really skews things, but:
excluding the Sox 16-2 record against the NL, they are a sub .500 team. They've underachieved tremendously this year sans the beating they threw in the NL.
I really think they hinged their hopes on Beckett being dominant, Schilling being Schilling, Wells being healthy, Clement being the Apr-July pitcher he was last year, the young arms contributing strongly, and Foulke being the 2004 Foulke.
they got only 2 of the 6 above ( 1.schilling and 2. I'll say Paps single-handedly fulfilled the young-arm expectation, while the other youngsters were so-so at best).
My hunch is the Sox inability to get something done at the trade deadline was twofold. First its an admission that the team was flawed enough that the FO knew no moves were going to make them a strong WS title contender; yet at the same time they were still close enough in the playoff hunt that they could not become sellers, lest they pi$$ off the throngs. In some ways, it mighta been better of they fell out of the race earlier.
The winds of change are blowing. So where do they go? What will the Sox look like next year? Some of our likely departing players or question marks:
Foulke: FA...should be gone...there's a mutual option on him. Sox won't exercise that.
Seanez: FA...team option..bwahahahahaha
AGonz: FA...I like him. or should I say I DID like him?
Loretta: FA
Wakefield: FA...team option...Sox FO will exercise the option
Crisp: the CF experiment failed. He is movable as his salary isn't huge and he is still young. I think he'd perform better out of the bright lights and if there are potential replacents (G. Matthews Jr, A. Jones? or Juan Pierre (was his ever extended after his trade? other options?)
Kapler: FA ...please go away so Francona doesn't have an excuse to keep giving you playing time.
Trot: FA..gone
Other FAs: Cora, Mirabelli (i think is a FA) and Timlin...do the Sox make a push to resign any of these guys?
Ramirez: You know he's on the block, its an offseason ritual and with his committed dollars decreasing he becomes a more and more viable part of a trade. I'd hate to see him go, but in the right deal the FO will move him and his remaining $.
I expect the Sox to make a run at Gil Meche, the 27 yr old righty with Seattle. Any other SPs they should shoot for?
By the way, I still haven't given up total hope....I mean they are only 6 outta the WC...hey ya never know....maybe...ahhhhh, faaaaaaak. so what do they look like next year?