I still think not signing Damon to that kind of money was the right move. I think the difference between the market last year and the market this year is that if Damon was a free agent this year, he'd be getting Carlos Lee type money. I do think that Crisp will improve on his 2006 season once his hand is fully healthy. I also remember that Damon, when he first came to Boston, he didn't set people's hair on fire with his stats.
2002
Games - 154
Avg. - .286
HR - 14
RBI - 63
OBP - .356
SLG - .443
2003
Games - 145
Avg. - .273
HR - 12
RBI - 67
OBP - .345
SLG - .405
Compare that to Crisp's 2006:
Games - 105
Avg. - .264
HR - 8
RBI - 36
OBP - .317
SLG - .385
I do agree that Crisp will never be as big of an OBP guy as Damon, but I see no reason why he can't be a .285/15/75 type player when healthy, in fact I think he has the potential to be better than that.
Crisp is not as good as Damon right now, but I do think the two will be comparable in the coming years. Maybe not next year, but two or three down the road.
Edgar Renteria 2004 - .287/10/72/.327/.401 (AVG/HR/RBI/OBP/SLG)
Edgar Renteria 2005 - .276/8/70/.335/.385
He OPS'd .728 in '04, and .720 in '05. The difference between the two years is he had a terrible defensive year, hurt his back, and never got back into playing shape. But he essentially had identical offensive years in '04 and '05.