To me it is. Youk is a Gold Glove at 1st, can play a solid 3rd in a pinch, and does a ton at the plate. He just uses up arms with the amount of pitches he sees. Crisp is arguably one of the best defensive outfielders in the AL and may still be better at the plate than he's shown. I think the thumb injury took a long time to get right and a hand injury like that is crippling to a hitter, affecting both bat head speed and bat control. Lester has proven himself to be game ready. Lowrie is great trade bait at this point despite taking it on the chin in the AFL.
Crisp, Lowrie, Lester or more likely Buchholz. A fourth would have to be a minor leager, IMO. I have no idea what the statisticians say on this one.