2005 - top is Award winner Bartolo Colon, bottom is Johan Santana
2003- top is Tim Hudson, bottom is award winner Roy Halladay
2004- Top is Randy Johnson, bottom is award winner Roger Clemens
2005- Top is award winner Chris Carpenter, bottom is Roger Clemens
The last two are crazy. Clemens threw almost the exact same number of innings, and had an ERA almost 1 full point lower than his ERA the previous year, against a man who had a higher ERA than the challenger the previous year in similar innings. But Carpenter won 21 games. Clemens 13.