It is relevant towards a discussion of him getting his "due" (whatever that is), as a player's image is a very important part of how that player, employee, politician, person, is judged by his friends, coworkers, peers, media, etc...
When will A-Rod get his due?
I play soccer at a fairly competitive level, with some former low level pros and a lot of other players who are half decent but just think they are better than they are.
I am not the most skilled soccer player. I have the first touch of a rapist and no matter what I do on the field, I can NOT put the ball in the net.
What I AM, is the hardest, smartest worker on the field every time I step on it. The way I play commands the respect of everyone else on the field. Why? Because on that field I am an overachiever. I do more than I should be able to with the talent that I have been given.
In life, we tend to gravitate towards the little guy- the Dustin Pedroia who will never make it in the bigs, the Wes Welker type who manages to cut between players with feet on him in size and hundreds of pounds in weight. We root for the 15 seed busting its ass to beat that full-of-itself 2 that would have been a 1 if it had hit its potential. Personally, I can not STAND playing ball with players who are blessed with talent and are no better than I am because they don't work hard enough and don't try hard enough.
Maybe J.D. Drew is the consummate professional- handling the game like a job rather than a passion, always on an even keel. Dustin Pedroia is the guy in sales, yukking it up with everyone he sees and scoring sales for the firm, while J.D. Drew is working in the backroom in the accounting department quietly earning his keep for the firm. Maybe that is the best way for anyone to handle the game, (and lets not forget, that is what it is, a game). Or maybe it is just the best way for him to handle the game. After all, we need an accountant, but we need a salesman too.
What it isn't though, is endearing to most fans. It presents the attitude of someone who doesn't care much, who isn't utilizing all of his talents, all of his power, to milk everything that he can out of the game. Is that the case? I don't know. But if his peers are calling him an underachiever, that is quite the indictment that there is more behind his attitude than the "consummate professional." That would insinuate apathy, which is not follwed by adoration.
Whether or not J.D. Drew is underachieving has everything to do with this discussion.