FWIW, going by winshares, Lugo is actually one of the best defenders this year. His 2.6 winshares puts him in 3rd in the MLB among SS and 4th most winshares of any position in MLB. Though his bat hasnt come around yet.
And Cabrera = no Ellsbury
And again fwiw, Pedro = no Clay Buchholz
And Dice-K is a very good pitcher, despite what his ERA tells you as Kilo mentioned. His streak over the past games has been very good (he was very sick last outing, I wont hold that against him). 18 wins and an ERA around 3.50 is my prediction for Dice in his first seaosn.