All the writers that voted for Joe Gordon over Ted Williams are dead. There was an outcry then about the disparity in statistics, and generations of sportswriters have come and gone and it is still a popularity contest. The intangible that is at play is not what most people think it is. The X factor is not about being a leader or a winner. It is about giving the writers access and be accommodating. If a guy is good copy and accessible, he will have the advantage. It is human nature, and it is a popularity contest by the people whose job it is to cover the players. That will never change.