I suggest that you re-read my post. You said that you could not be an elite offensive player if you strike out 150+ times a year. I merely pointed out the fact that ARod has struck out 131 and 139 times in the last 2 years. He is, as you stated, in the top 5 offensive players. I think his high K totals rebuffs your theory on the relation of K's to whether or not someone can be an elite offensive player. I made no comparison between the two players. Before you make an assumption as to the meaning of a post and call it the "dumiest post of all time," you should take a second read of the post to make sure it says what you think it says. I clearly did not make the comparison. You are double owned.
BTW What is "dumiest"? My goodness.
Also, I think the term "elite players" can be extended beyond the top 5 players.