You should be upset, because he was supposed to be a manager who demanded sound fundamentals from his team. He can't help that his players got injured or that the FO gave him 3 rookie pitchers for the rotation, but he failed at the one thing for which he has no excuse. There's no excuse that this team is so poor at executing fundamentals. They are worse than any Joe Torre team. It is not just the kids, but it's the veterans as well. That shows me that Girardi either does not stress the fundamentals (in which case he did not come as advertised) or that he stresses the fundamentals but the team is not responding to him. The latter is worse than the former. If the team is not responding to him, he should be fired. I hope he stays, because I feel very strongly that he is a terrible manager. BTW without calling him a failure, Michael Kay made the same exact point about how Girardi was expected to stress fundamentals, but noted how poor this team was in that regard.
I did have another quote that is being used in a signature about the Yankees having no chance, because they are made up of rookies and old men. That statement was very early in the season. It is very uncharacteristic of me to stick a fork in the Yankees before they are mathematically eliminated, but the make up of this team with two untested rookies in the rotation made it clear to me early on that they had no chance. Blame injuries all you want, but if Hughes and Kennedy had stayed healthy they would have sported something like a 4-16 record. They would have had to been sent down whether or not they got injured. They had no chance with 2 rookies in the rotation and more in the pen. The only reason they stayed this close is because Moose shocked everyone and had a great season.