My initial posts were to express the fact that Schilling should have Carte Blanche with Red Sox fans who I reminded that the Sox haven't won a Championship without him. That post was met with a response that Schilling wouldn't have made a difference this season. I didn't know how that conclusion could be reached, so I pointed out that Schilling had never been trashed like the Sox pitchers were trashed in those 3 straight games. I used game 4 as an example where I thought he could have made a difference. Substituting Schilling for Wakefield in a post season game seemed to be the no-brainer example of a game where he could have made the difference. I don't think anyone would ever start Wakefield over Schilling in a post season game, and I don't think it is a stretch to say that Schilling probably would have fared better than Wakefield who was gave up a few nitro-shots. Schilling for Wakefield is a no-brainer. Would it guarantee a game 4 win? No, but it is not a big stretch to say that he might have made the difference in that game. He's shut down better hitting teams in big games. You really don't need to analyze all the variables. He's a much better big game pitcher than Wakefield, and Wakefield stunk up the place on that night.