In his best season, he set a record for the fewest innings by a pitcher with 18 wins. That was his high point, and I would sign on for two more years of that in a heart beat, and that would be far from being a bust. However, that season was his one high spot. It's been downhill since then, and I don't think he is going to return to that form. He has been an inconsistent performer with injury issues. Like I said in an earlier post, I thought 2010 would be a big year for him. I felt that he was at a crossroads and that he would emerge as a top pitcher. He did not. I have no reason to think that he will come up big in his final two seasons. In fact, I expect his performance will continue to deteriorate. If his last two years are more of the same performance as 2010 or worse, I think his signing would have to be viewed as a mistake.