They all stink and they are all overpaid. Those bad contracts don't make Dice K's look any better. The only one that had a good track record was Zito, but it was clear that he just could no longer throw with any velocity. The others were just different degrees of mediocrity, and those were stupid contracts, but they were about half the cost of Dice K's contract.. There is no debating the posting fee. Just because it doesn't hit payroll for luxury tax purposes doesn't mean that it isn't real money. It was a $52 million expense, for which they received nothing other than an exclusive right to negotiate. He cost them $104 million, no matter how you slice it. The posting fee is a bigger financial blunder than the salary, because Dice K's salary and the salaries of Meche, Lilly and Suppan were spread over several years making them worth much less than the $52 million lump sum posting fee paid in 2006. The time value of the money makes the posting expense even more egregiously wasteful.