None of these are comparable to Papelebon. I have noted my reasons. BTW, if you wanted to make a fair comparison, you should have noted that a number of these closers were hugely successful through age 34 (e.g. Nathan, Wagner and Hoffman) which is when Papelbon's new contract will end.
2) Lidge 2009-2011, Never had Papelbon's consistency or success-- just not as good
3)K-rod 2009-2011, Stats okay, 6 blown saves per year, but he turned into a PR/clubhouse nightmare. Stats okay. That's really all that matters. He's still a performer
4)Joe Nathan 2008-2011 Signed his contract at age 34-- older than Papelbon
5) Soriano 2011--2013 Same age as Papelbon, but never had Papelbon's consistency or success-- simply not as good as Papelbon
6) Billy Wagner 2006-2009 --Older than Papelbon-- signed his contract at age 34
7)Trevor Hoffman 2010-- 5.89 ERA.Way older than Papelbon-- signed his contract at age 39
8) Kerry Wood --2009-2010, Not comparable in any way shape or form to Papelbon
9) Broxton 2010-2011-- Broxton never had Papelbon's consistency and success. He's just not as good