It's obvious why I didn't mention Adam Jones. He is one of the two good hitters in the O's lineup yesterday- the other being Markakis. Jones is good and getting better. Bard should have approached yesterday's game with the attitude that he wasn't going to let Jones or Markakis beat him and that he owned everyone else. Instead he is walking 4 guys, hitting another and he fed Nick Johnson a cookie. He did keep his team in the game against a weak lineup and he went 5 innings. That's the positive side of the ledger. On the negative side, yesterday he again showed that he is simply not developing as a starter. There has been no progress or improvement. If the long range plan with this conversion was to take a top end of game reliever-- a real weapon and turn him into a serviceable #5 starter, they have succeeded. He is a serviceable #5, and he is showing no signs that he is has the capability of being any more than that. If that was the plan, it was a very poor plan. We could have gotten a serviceable #5 elsewhere cheaply and easily. I thought the idea was to convert a special bullpen arm into a special starter. That appears to be a failure.
I expected bumps in the road in this conversion-- painful games where he would get lit up, but I also expected some flashes of exceptional potential. I have not seen any instances of that. I expected that he would have exceptional stuff-- a 95 MPH heater and a devastating slider. He has had very ordinary stuff. I expected that there would be slow but discern able improvement and progression. There has not been any of that either. They will continue this experiment mainly because it takes Cherries a long time to make decisions, but he is just wasting time on this experiment. I fear it will end with Bard on the DL.