This forum does have tendency to brand people thus making it hard for them to stick around very long. Pom pom wavers have a much better chance of staying than posters with critical analysis.
Usually, banning is not rampant and many poster get away with stuff that shouldn't be tolerated. However, in a trying time like this season, there was less tolerance for negativity. I think negativity is appropriate when there is a solid basis in fact for negativity. There was absolutely no rational reason to think that Bard would be a solid starter with a mid-3's ERA, yet people posted those projections. There were plenty of facts and good reasons to believe that he would fall on his face. The posters who thought the Sox were toast on opening day are all gone with one exception. SCM is the only one left, and he probably would have been banned if he had posted more regularly. All of the pom pom wavers are still around and some are still looking for excuses, but the utter and complete failure of this team makes it almost impossible for even the most positive fanatic to find scapegoats. As some of the negative posters correctly pointed out, the organization has been poorly run in almost every aspect for several years already. This FO took over a talented roster, a competitive deep team, and after its initial notable successes they have driven the organization to the level of the teams like the Guardians and Mariners at all levels. They have returned this team to its status of the late 50's and early 1960's in a few short seasons. They had to be extraordinarily inept to manage such a precipitous fall in stature with a payroll of $170 million. Those who saw the signs and were willing to say so were denigrated as lousy fans and banned because they made us uncomfortable. There is a possibility that we could suck for a few years, because the same guys that helped to ruin the team are still in place. Maybe Cherington was not the problem and he will finally get his chance to shine. We can hope. If we suck for a few more years, we will have some pom pom wavers posting in April and May each season only to disappear when things go bad and this will be a lonely place with just a few tolerated posters who allowed to engage in critical analysis.