Au contraire Kilo. I saw him several times and in all those occasions he played horrible in the outfield. On Fenway's Opening Day 2006 I was him play a routine fly ball off his glove for a two run homer, turning a 5-1 breather into a 5-3 nailbiter. You know about his YS adventures, and I also saw him on TV in 2005 as a member of the Reds when he played a fly ball off his head for a homer off the Pesky Pole. Now that may still not be a large enough sample for you, but it certainly seems to me that it is enough to tell me that this guy still hasn't learned how to effectively track a fly ball. In CF? Well he is better, but, please, don't say LF. He can't play out there either. As for Manny, he is much better in the outfield that meets the eye. Again a small sample but I saw him make some outstanding plays in Boston, Anaheim and New York.