Great post EX; you hit it on all cylinders. Where I have my doubts, though, are with Pineiro and Romero. Romero cannot pitch worth a damn against the Yankees and if doesn't have his control, which is often, he is not that much help with lefties. If he has his control, then he could be used that way and THAT WAY ONLY. No way he becomes our main lefty in the bullpen, not after shithole seasons with the Twins and Angels. He might be on his way down. As for Piniero, the human pin cushion, the last three years should have told Theo all he needed to know about this guy and that he is a disaster waiting to happen.
On the other fronts you were a spot-on. Getting Drew and Lugo strenghtened our hitting attack, Dice K our rotation, and Okajima and Donnelly our bullpen. The only place where Theo "might" have failed is in getting that reserve catcher we all thought we needed, but even here Mirabelli has gotten off to a flying start and in the telecast yesterday Buck and McCarver were bemoaning the Yankees' shortage in that area while throwing bouquets at our situation with Doug. It must have killed McCarver to have to say that, though.
Zito is coming around for the Giants, however. He has pitched two gems in a row, and Schmidt may come around when his shoulder inflamation heals. Still, like you, I will go with Matsuzaka. That was far and away the best move we could have made for our starting pitching from my vantage point.