I doubt 2 years would remove that much, I'd still much ratehr have Tek blocking home before Posada, the knock against him last season was his offense, lets not carry it over to his D. Plus Posada, while throwing out 30% also had 129 attempts to do so in 2005, whereas Tek only had 86 attempts against him, I think it's safe to say MLB teams would run more often if they faced worse throwing, whther it be accuracy or what have you.
Yeah, he improved, but no way he had a "very good season". His RAA of 15 speaks for itself.
Crisp's F% was better, I'll give him a slight edge in arm strength though it is somewhat dubious, and his RFg was better as well. Just fyi, I was giving this is a slight edge, as their lgF%s and RF9 are both even.
Drew ahs the better range, while Abreu has the better F%, that's why I gave Drew the edge with the better arm.