if Graff hits a walk-off homer on opening day, gets traded the next day, and the sox win the AL east by 1 game and go onto win the world series, then damn right he should get a ring
but then if a guy plays 5 games for the sox and is designated for assignment, how do you tell him he doesnt get a ring?
regardless of everything else, anyone who had even the smallest effect on the clubhouse during a given year, had an effect on how the team did that team