I'm not picking and choosing arguments. The pitching staff has been the major problem with this team for several years, not the offense which is why I say letting Pedro walk was a mistake but letting Damon walk wasn't. Last season, the rotation was absolutely pathetic, this season, it's been in shambles aside from Schilling and the emergence of Lester.
Run production has been a luxury we've had for several years now. Just look at this year, we let Damon go and replace him with Coco and we're still near the top of the league in runs. And replacing Damon with Coco didn't hinder the defense either.
So because of that, a long-term deal for Pedro would've been a lot easier to swallow than a long-term deal for Damon