He doesnt trust his defense like he used to.....you are right and its pretty clear they are nowhere close to what they once were. I am not arguing that.
I dont see it as a "no-no" to go for it on fourth down. How many times have you found yourself screaming at the TV to "go for it". Unlike most teams, we have a coach who has the balls to put the petal to the medal. 4th and less than 1 with Brady quick snapping a qb sneak has a high percentage conversion rate. Its almost automatic.
In the last couple of years, a study was actually done showing that going for it on 4th down might actually be better than punting the ball, assuming you are on your opponents side of the field. Here is a link to that study:
http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~dromer/papers/JPE_April06.pdf
Ever think that the reason he goes for it so much is because he considers that a better scheme than punting the ball? Its great to pin a team inside the 20, but that is rarer than we think. Most likely the result will be touchback, and the punt gained 20 total net yards. Why not go for it and at least move the ball, kill some clock and try to get some points out of it? Its better than no points at all. Ever think that maybe BB is ahead of the curve?? (as he almost always is).
I loved what Randy did in 07. I loved what he did for Matt Cassel in 08, but last year he started to wear on me. Last year he started his s***, it was only a matter of time. Give the Patriots credit, they diagnosed and got rid of the cancer before it became terminal.
Randy Moss was NEVER 100% motivated this year. Like I said, this was only going to get worse. It was never going to get better. Shame on Moss, he dug his own grave. If you dont give 100% to BB and this team all game, every game.....he will replace you. It doesnt matter who you are. Nobody is above the team on that squad. BB says it over and over....."do your job", Randy Moss clearly did not and met his demise.