I agree. A run is a run.
Here are some of my thoughts though. A leadoff hitter, is only a leafoff hitter ONCE in the game. After that, its all about matchups. The best hitter in your lineup is your #3 hitter, therefore....you want guys in front of him who get on base. I dont care if they are fat, fast, skinny, slow......it doesnt matter.
Ive spoken to Dipre about this (my lineup proposal), he disagrees with me, but so be it. The best player on the team at getting on base is JD Drew (and it pains me to say it, bc I cant stand him).
What about a lineup of:
RF Drew
2B Pedroia
1B Agon
3B Youkilis
DH Ortiz
SS Scutaro
LF Crawford
C Salty
CF Ellsbury
Remember, the leadoff hitter only leads off once. You want guys who get on base in front or your best hitter. Drew and Pedroia are not slouches on the basepaths, in fact both are very good baserunners. Most people want to put Ellsbury and Crawford back to back....but I think that splitting them up extends the lineup. This lineup also provides power throughout. The lineup maintains a LH/RH mathcup.
Most importantly, the lineup has a bunch of speed at the bottom of the lineup to set the table for guys who take a bunch of pitches (Drew) which allows for SB opportunities which puts guys in scoring position for contact guys (Pedroia) and also allows the best hitters in your lineup (Youk and Agon) to get a TON of ABs with guys cluttering the bases (Crawford, Ellsbury, Drew, Pedroia). Think about how crazy it would be for Youk and Agon getting all those opportunities to drive in those guys.