As for the Johnny Damon/Coco Crisp comparison. Here's one that speaks volume.
Damon's First 4 seasons
47 games- (.282 avg) (.314 OBP) (.441 SLG) (.765 OPS) 3 Hrs, 23 RBIs
145 games- (.271 avg) (.313 OBP) (.368 SLG) (.680 OPS) 6 Hrs, 50 RBIs
146 games- (.275 avg) (.338 OBP) (.386 SLG) (.723 OPS) 8 Hrs, 48 RBIs
161 games- (.277 avg) (.339 OBP) (.439 SLG) (.779 OPS) 18 HRs. 66 RBIs
Crisp's First 4 seasons
32 games- (.260 avg) (.314 OBP) (.386 SLG) (.700 OPS) 1 HR, 9 RBIs
99 games- (.266 avg) (.302 OBP) (.353 SLG) (.655 OPS) 3 Hrs, 27 RBIs
139 games- (.297 avg) (.344 OBP) (.446 SLG) (.790 OPS) 15 Hrs, 71 RBIs
145 games- (.300 avg) (.345 OBP) (.465 SLG) (.810 OPS) 16 Hrs, 69 RBIs