I'm allowed to like a player better, am I not? As much as I like Felix I have grown attached to Dice-K already. I like it that he's entirely healthy. I like it that he's already poised and experienced. And I like it that he's a Red Sox for 6 seasons.
I love Felix too, but given that this is a hypothetical discussion about a trade that would never happen, I made my opinion known based on opinion and subjectivity... kind of like the root of the question.
EDIT: Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's pitcher
EDIT: Would "nah, I like Dice-K better" have been acceptable if he had outpitched Felix tonight? I have no doubt in my mind that he can, given Felix's history of control problems and the inevitability of a bad day.