Well put jacksonian. Truth be told, I brought up the comparison because Gom said to imagine losing Drew and Varitek. In part I did the comparison BECAUSE it shows the different constructions of our teams. Losing Drew and Varitek would be a BIGGER deal to our team than this is to the Yankees, and I think the proof is in the pudding. Yes, your team still raked because of two guys coming through when it mattered: A-Rod and Giambi. But don't do your team too much of a disservice, Cano is a great offensive player, Abreu is a great offensive player, A-Rod has been hitting like Babe Ruth, Jeter is possibly the most consistent hitting SS in the past 25 years, Damon is a great player, etc.,
Yes, your pitching was weak this series. But you can't blame the starters for Mariano's meltdown. It also is easier to shut down the Red Sox than it is to shut down the Yankees, even with an injury or two to the Yanks.
I guess my point is that this is baseball. Yeah, maybe next week it will look better for the Yanks. Maybe it won't. I think there's reason to think that injuries will continue for this team, especially the starters. Last year when the Sox got swept in 5 games very few people around here took the injury excuse as legitimate. They didn't get why we couldn't win even a game or two. That too is baseball.
Losing Posada and Matsui is a big deal. But those two aren't the guys people think about when they think about the Yankees offense. Those players are first A-Rod, second Jeter, and then possibly matsui with Abreu and Giambi. Those three guys are tremendous. All three of them are as good as Drew, at least in terms of production on a consistent basis.
I guess my thinking on it is that during the regular season good pitching often DOES NOT beat good hitting. Good patient hitting can manage to succeed against great pitchers. This Yankees team having good ABs against matsuzaka doesn't make Matsuzaka a bad pitcher, nor Beckett, nor Schilling. Those guys who comprise our "vaunted" pitching staff are deservedly vaunted.
Against any other team, even the best offenses, they will find plenty of success. Let's compare the Yankees offense with the Twins and Tigers offense from today:
Here's the Yankees:
Damon
Jeter
Abreu
A-Rod
Giambi
Cano
Dougy
Cabrera
Nieves
And the Twins:
Casilla
Punto
Mauer
Cuddyer
Morneau
Hunter
Redmond
Rabe
Bartlett
And the Tigers:
Granderson
Polanco
Infante
Ordonez
Guillen
Thames
Casey
Rabelo
Inge
These are other good MLB teams, but their offenses are considerably weaker, even than the yankees offense today. Other than Morneau and possibly Mauer I don't see anyone who would even be discussed as being part of the yankees 1-6.
My overall point is that the yankees, even when injured, have an offense that is better than anyone elses. What they lack is pitching, which has nothing to do with offensive injuries. Therefore, it should have little bearing on whether or not Matsuzaka will be a "good pitcher" overall, or whether the SP should be seen as Vaunted. This core of SP was able to work out victories against an offense that, other than perhaps the Mets, is the best in all of baseball.
I'm not going to downplay that. Yes, the Yankees offense has been better in the past, and even then, with healthy pitching, the sox took them to 7 games in 03 and 7 games in 04. The Sox can win and compete with this team either way. each game is going to have its unique flavor and you'll win some you'll lose some.
As you can probably tell, I would have said the exact same thing if the Sox had lost. It wouldn't be the end of the world and it isn't for the Yankees. I just don't want to hear excuses about not having enough offense. You don't hear the Twins saying that or the Tigers saying that, even when they're throwing their #4 or #5 starters. It is up to THEM to work out victories in those matches. Furthermore, it was the yankees bullpen that was supposed to be so good and the saving grace during this period of injuries.
I expect that the Yankees will go back to their murderous ways tomorrow, and the day after, and the day after. I'm just sick of hearing excuses abou tthe Yankees lacking certain huge parts of their lineup when they have spent so much damn money on their team.
By saying that the Yankees have spent their money to make an offensive juggernaught, are you condemning their approach? It sounds like you are praising having a balanced team with pitching and hitting. I would agree with that assessment.
Offense will get you places, but we have seen the past few years that adding another big hitter doesn't suddenly make you unstoppable. MLB hitters will make poor pitchers pay eventually. What should be concerning is Mariano's downfall thus far.
Also, he's on my fantasy team as part of my "win-win" strategy. Same with Jeter. If they do well my fantasy team does well, if they don't then my real team does well. :thumbsup:
I'm rambling. Perhaps we could send my posts to guiness to see if I've broken some record.