Making your argument based on one hit in a postseason game makes no sense at all. Prior performance in a single game, postseason or no, should not factor in to resigning a player. After the 2011 World Series, David Freese could have received the key to the city of St. Louis while having anal sex with the mayor's underage daughter during the ceremony. And what did he accomplish for the Cardinals in the 2013 World Series? Take a look at some of the Cardinal fan's Twitter feeds. You would be convinced the man single-handedly planned and executed 9/11. Dave Roberts stole the most important base in the history of Boston Red Sox baseball, and he was gone the next season. Aaron Boone had one of the most dramatic home runs in Yankee history, but that's the only thing anyone ever remembers about him, aside from his having the most redneck-sounding name in the history of organized sports besides maybe Bubba Watson. I'm open to arguments for or against guys like Middlebrooks and Drew and Bogaerts, but the only performances that should be used as debate points are season-long performances, not nine-inning performances.