W+EXACTLY. But we don't have to worry about that. Jeter isn't that type. He doesnt care. He'll let the award come to him in a quiet, classy manner.
Well why do you think Ortiz deserves it more than Jeter? Let me guess, is it because Ortiz plays solid defense? Or how about his ability to move runners over via sac bunts, opposite field hits,and legging out ground balls? How about his baserunning ability? How about the fact that he defied odds and led his team, which was hit by a hurricaine of injuries, to the playoffs?
..i'm guessing it's none of those. Big Papi is a one dimensional player who can just hit Home Runs and drive runs in. Jeter can do everything, and do it well. Jeter's versatility as a player isn't credited enough.
And lets not forget that Derek Jeter will be playing baseball next month, David Ortiz won't be because his team couldn't hold onto a season-long lead in front of a team that had 13 different players on the DL, including Matsui, Sheffield, Dotel, Cano, Mussina, etc.
I know you guys can blame a lot on injuries as well, but we took the division lead before any of your significant injuries occured, so that arguement doesn't hold ground, sorry. So spare me.
He sure does. I dont care what you guys say, Derek Jeter plays a very good defensive shortstop.
I also think it's ridiculous. Mark Loretta, Wily Mo, Manny, Trot Nixon, Varitek, etc. arent bad players. The fact that they have underacheiving and injured players can't be an excuse because the Yankees have dealt with exactly the same and didn't complain about it.
Nobody said baseball players had to be classy, but Ortiz has a classy reputation, so these statements could sort of protray him as a phony.
Great Post
Why does Jeter deserve criticism because he's a smart man who knows how to handle the media and knows exactly what to say? As for why he should or shouldnt make it to the hall of fame, your arguements and points are great ones, if you're talking about just any schmo. Jeter is a special player. He is a champion, clutch hitter, icon, role model, leader, and captain. There are things beyond stats that need to be taken into consideration.
That's really relevant.