I don't watch every baseball game there is....got other things to do. I also know the difference between a good pitcher and a bad pitcher. I also know the difference between talent and production. I'm fully aware of how Justin Verlander pitches and I'm not saying he isn't going to be an excellent pitcher. In fact he is already the best pitcher on the Detroit Tigers staff (in my opinion). Despite pitching against Minnesota, Seattle, Oakland, Kansas City...he has been fantastic. I am not going to take away from what Jonathan Papelbon has done though. He is the top closer in baseball at the moment (even if he does play for the Red Sox). I've seen both players pitch and I'd gladly take either. Down the road I honestly can't tell you who will be better.....depends how teams adjust to them.
As far as Zumaya and Hansen I can't really say cause I have never seen Zumaya pitch.
On a side note....with the success Liriano, Verlander, Papelbon, Cain (great game the other day), Loe....why do people still think Jon Lester can't help the Red Sox?? He is supposed to be around the category of those guys yet I still see people talk about him in the same sentence as Cla Meredith. He is not Cla Meredith, won't have the same career, so why are people afraid to use him?