Nomar was really bad defensive SS in 2004, and 99.9% of great baseball men had no idea that Nomar told Theo that his achilles was not going to hold up in August.
From Theo Epstein:
Besides, what the f*** does this have to do with anything? Increase the awareness that a deal like that happens .0001% of the time?
If you're talking about the Erik Bedard who was Cy Young award material in 2007, you'd have a point, but Bedard's value is way down. He's not even healthy right now.
According to FRAA, and defensive win shares, Jose Reyes is considered the better defensive player over the last year and a half.
2007 + 2008 WS
Reyes - 7.8
Betancourt - 7.3
http://www.hardballtimes.com/thtstats/main/index.php?view=winshares&linesToDisplay=50&orderBy=field&direction=DESC&season_filter%5B%5D=2008&league_filter%5B%5D=All&team_filter%5B%5D=All&pos_filter%5B%5D=SS&Submit=Submit
If you look at FRAA, the margin gets even wider.
2007-2008 FRAA
Betancourt - -20
Reyes - +12
I haven't even mentioned that Betancourt has a .280 OBP this year.
Making a trade that makes the Mets worse, will help them this year?
Where does Reed play?
Beltran is firmly entrenched in CF, and Reed doesn't have the bat for a corner. In fact, his career OPS .688.
This is a substantial downgrade offensively, and at best a wash defensively. They upgrade the rotation, but it isn't enough to justify trading Reyes away.
2008 WS - 12 (3rd)
2007 WS - 24 (5th)
2006 WS - 29 (2nd)
Wrong.
Jeter, Hardy, Theriot, and Stephen Drew?
lol