We'd be fools to do it.
Murphy can play LF, CF, or RF. That being said, if someone wants him. I'd be willing to trade him. He's a fourth outfielder.
Pedroia reminds you of Gallego? Why? Because he's small?
Gallego: .247/.326/.297/.623
Pedroia: .310/.398/.473/.871
He may not be Tejada, but he's certaintly not Gallego.
I'd part with Delcarmen and Murphy for Smoltz. The Braves wouldn't, so it's a moot point.
That's a good point, but the Red Sox would still be on the hook for $25 million dollar for two unproductive players. I don't know, maybe Martinez becomes Roger Clemens and dominates into his late 30's. History certaintly points against it, but it's possible that Pedro could do it. Do you think it's possible that Pedro is having a good year because he is pitching in an inferior league?
No one expects them to do that. Expecting them to be solid arms in the bullpen is a fair expectation.
Laugh all you want. It won't be close to kind of deal you envisioned.