You just posted that on NetSports, so I might as well put my responses on here as well:
Post 1: There are no guarantees that Beltran and Varitek re-sign, that is the huge sticking point.
Varitek has been a big part of this franchise since 1998. Don't you think he would have re-signed by now if he had every intention to return? He's going to test the market and see what he can get. With the money he's asking for and the high level that Shoppach has been playing at since mid-May, I don't see Varitek returning.
So, if a player who's been a cornerstone of the franchise for 6 years doesn't re-sign before the season is done, what makes you think that the superstar center-fielder who would have only been here for 3-4 months is going to do so? They have the same agent and the exact same intention: to test the free agent market.
Folks, this doesn't make any sense. Beltran is going to go on the market and the Yankees are going to make a huge bid for him. We know the Sox can spend, but they cannot spend like the Yankees can. We would be giving up two great, cheap players and positions of need for the Red Sox (who are both ready to start in '05, probably even later this season) for a three to four month rental who will just go to play for the Yankees next season.
What the Sox need to do is shore up their rotation first. Let's get Schill's ankle, Wake's thumb, Kim's back and Lowe's psyche back on track and then see where this pitching staff is. We do not need to make changes to the offense that broke the all-time SLG% record. We need to start preventing runs.
Post 2: Another thing to consider are the holes that we would create in other aspects of the team after the season is done. So the Sox sign Beltran for $15 million a season. That means Pedro, Williamson, Lowe, Varitek and Nomar would all have to be sacrificed in order to do so. Now we need two more starting pitchers, a set-up man, a SS and a C (because Shoppach was foolishly traded away). Hey, at least we have the super star center-fielder. Guys, if we do this we are turning into the Texas Rangers.
We should wait for Kim to come back, see how he performs and then make a trade for a pitcher based upon his and others' performances.