Carlos Narváez Is Getting Eaten Alive By Fastballs, but the Red Sox Shouldn't Lose Hope

I think you are way too optimistic about Narvaez.  He's a Yankee cast off who didn't perform for NY and came to Boston to replace Wong a Dodger cast off who never performed well in LA or in Boston except for ONE season.  His career year got everyone believing in him while ignoring his past seasons of failure.  His encore was miserable in 2025 just like his years prior to 2024.  I explained at the start of last season when Narvaez was hot that it was an anomaly based on past performance and that like Wong his career year in 2025 would regress him into oblivion in 2026 just like Wong the year before.  In the meantime, Breslow screwed up big-time by including Teel in the Crochet deal.  Mayer was more famous and should have been the key to the deal, so Montgomery didn't have to be included.  With higher value from Mayer the Red Sox could have lowered the remaining value slightly from Montgomery to someone like Arias.  That would have kept the next Varitek in Boston and got rid of the next Jeter Downs (Mayer) to Chicago.  Huge mistake by Breslow and Boston is going to pay for it until they find another great young catcher.  ONE YEAR WONDERS like Wong and Narvaez don't solidify a franchise they simply mislead the fan base to expect growth out of sub-standard starters.  

You are welcome think tinkering with a swing will change the skill level of a player, but it won't.  Talent dictates success and neither Wong nor Narvaez have close to the talent that Teel has.  Mayer on the other hand is much closer in talent to Wong and Narvaez.  

There was a good reason LA dumped Jeter Downs, Wong and Verdugo in the Mookie deal.  Bloom was an idiot (actually he still is!!) and there is a reason NY gave up on Narvaez.  Breslow seems to either hit on a great deal or a terrible deal and very little in between.  Good Crochet except for the Teel part, bad on Sale, good on Bregman, bad on Buehler, Sandoval and Giolito and hopefully good on Gray and Suarez.  Losing Bregman remains a huge mistake and gaining Contreras seems like another mistake that coupled with the Bregman mistake makes the Red Sox corner infield their Achilles Heel.

3 hours ago, TedYazPapiMookie said:

Breslow screwed up big-time by including Teel in the Crochet deal.  Mayer was more famous and should have been the key to the deal, so Montgomery didn't have to be included.

I think that is pure conjecture on your part.

16 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

I think that is pure conjecture on your part.

Joe, absolutely because it's not what really happened BUT Mayer was much higher ranked and trades like that one often includes prospects based on their ranking.  The one thing to me that gives me confidence in what I am saying is that Quero was nearly as highly rated at catcher as Teel.  Who in their right mind chooses TWO catchers by trading for the second young catcher?  Mayer was a SS but could play (allegedly) at 2B, SS or 3B.  I often commented that Meidroth had a better minor league performance than Mayer, but he was NOT rated anywhere near Mayer.  So, the iffy part of what I said in my mind is the chances they might have pulled Montgomery because he was highly rated too.  The two gold chippers in the deal from Boston were Teel and Montgomery but if they bumped up the value from Teel to Mayer from a ranking perspective they would have had to lessen the value elsewhere in the deal.  Since neither Meidroth or Gonzalez had much ratings value then the downgrade should have been Montgomery OR they simply pull Meidroth or Gonzalez from the deal.  That's why the Montgomery part to me is the "unknown" part of what I wrote.  Clearly, Baseball America and the MLB Pipeline loved Mayer much more than both Teel or Montgomery and the White Sox had a great young catcher, it makes perfect sense that Breslow made the mistake of not seeing Mayer as the bust that he is and didn't include him in the trade.  He also didn't see Teel as the next coming of Fisk or Varitek.  Breslow was new at his job and has had as many bad evaluations as positive evaluations in his time as GM of Boston.  I will always respect him for dumping Devers and his bloated salary and disrespect him for not seeing the problem with Sale wasn't Sale it was Cora.  Sale has played for Ventura and Snitker and now Weiss for 10 years of his career and he's been awesome.  He played 7 years in Boston but only ONE year not for Cora (excluding 2020) and Farrell handled him great and he finished 2nd in the CY YOUNG voting.  He was a lock to win it in 2018 until Cora screwed with him and ruined his chances of winning (he finished 4th that year) and he ruined his career or at least derailed it for 7 years.  I blame the Sale trade to ATL on Cora.  Breslow should have recognized the BIGGEST issue in BOS other than Devers and that was/is Cora. 

It's three years later and Breslow has acquired lots of talent yet the team still can't win.  The problem is Cora and that should be obvious to even the unintelligent baseball fan but Cora got rehired by these owners and they clearly owe him because he should NEVER have been rehired.  They brought in Dombrowski and he turned the program around immediately and had 3 highly successful seasons.  They brought in Cora and if not for DD he wouldn't have had the talent to win in 2018 and he did his best to screw it up but the players overcame his ineptness as a manager.  The following year Cora's mistakes were more than any GM or set of players could off-set and the organization was destroyed and has proceeded downhill every since.

FIRE CORA and FIX THE PROBLEM 8 years too late.