Which Boston Red Sox Players Should Make The 2026 All-Star Game?

While the season hasn’t gone exactly as the Boston Red Sox or their fans hoped, there are still players on the roster worth celebrating. With the All-Star Game nearly here, it’s time to make some final predictions and see just who will head to Philadelphia to represent Boston and the rest of the American League.

While the Red Sox could have as many as seven players who are deserving of the honor, we’re going to breakdown the group under the assumption that it’ll be much like the past two seasons, when the team sent three representatives. Of course, nothing is set in stone, but with the official announcement coming tonight, these are our best guesses at Talk Sox.

Ranking Red Sox's 2026 All-Star Candidates

Most Likely All-Stars

Of the players on the roster, there are two that have really stood out as All-Stars (you could argue for a third, but we’ll touch on that later). Both individuals are part of the pitching staff in completely different roles. The first player is Aroldis Chapman. Chapman, pitching in his age-38 season has regressed slightly from last year but it would have been insane to expect a repeat of 2025. Instead, he’s been just as reliable, but with a couple hiccups on the mound due to a combination of defensive miscues and a nagging hamstring injury.

Despite that, the flamethrowing left-hander has put together one of the better seasons by a reliever as he’s allowed just six earned runs in 24 2/3 innings while saving 16 games. Much like last season, he’s been the dominant force to close out games for manager Chad Tracy while also racking up strikeouts, including a career-record-tying 1,363rd strikeout he got against the New York Yankees. Batters are reaching base a little bit more this year (19 hits and 12 walks compared to 28 and 15 in 61 1/3 innings last year), but a 30.2% strikeout rate helps to counteract that. Barring an unforeseen major injury, it’ll be a shock to not see Chapman be selected to his ninth All-Star Game.

Likely to join Chapman will be Sonny Gray, as the 36-year-old has put together a dominant first half despite spending time on the injured list. Gray has stepped up as the ace of the pitching staff in Garrett Crochet’s absence and has only delivered time and time again, including a 7 1/3 inning performance where he allowed just one hit to the Yankees. Overall, he’s started 15 games and given the team 83 2/3 innings with a 2.69 ERA. Record-wise, he’s gone 9-1 and has struck out 75 batters while walking opponents at a 6.2% rate. The numbers are all the more impressive when you realize he had a 4.30 ERA and just 13 strikeouts in his first five starts, including the one he left injured. Since returning, Gray has put together a dominant stretch of 10 starts with a 2.08 ERA across 60 2/3 innings while striking out 62 batters. If any player has turned a hot streak into an All-Star game appearance, it's this man.

Should Be There

This category encompasses two players that, for all intents and purposes, should be All-Stars, but due to the field in the American League will not be shocking (yet still disappointing) snubs.

The first player should be the most obvious. First baseman Willson Contreras has been the best offensive weapon for the Red Sox through the first half of the season as he’s put together a career year. Through 83 games, the right-handed batter has hit .283/.377/.529 with 14 doubles, two triples, 18 home runs and 53 RBIs. Defensively, he’s also played a great first base. However, Contreras has to deal with the likes of Vladimir Guerrero Jr, Ben Rice, Nick Kurtz, Pete Alonso and Munetaka Murakami (who will likely need an injury replacement should he be selected). Contreras should very much be in the previous category, but due to the quality of first basemen in the American League, I can’t bring myself to place him there.

Both Guerrero and Rice are the finalists for the starting first base spot, and should Rice fail to secure it, he’ll likely be selected to the roster after hitting .272/.362/.566 with 15 doubles, two triples, 22 home runs and 53 RBIs. That would likely leave one spot to go between Contreras, Alonso and Kurtz and it’s hard to leave Kurtz off of the All-Star team. That’s not even bringing up the argument that Alonso may make the team just because the Orioles need a representative

Joining Contreras in this section is Ceddanne Rafaela who, like always, has been one of the best center fielders in all of baseball. And unlike his previous seasons, he’s putting together his most complete season at the plate as well. Through 81 games, Rafaela has hit .282/.331/.435 (all career highs) along with 18 doubles, three triples, seven home runs and 35 RBIs, all while helping to bring consistency to the two-hole after the Red Sox tried multiple players there to no avail. Instead, Rafaela is on pace to walk more than in any previous season while also cutting his strikeouts back.

There is also some argument where if the All-Star Game was meant to showcase the best players in Major League Baseball, Rafaela would be selected based on his defense alone. Currently he’s in the 99th percentile for Fielding Run Value and Outs Above Average, going for 11 in both categories, showing just how important he is to the Red Sox's success on defense. And that’s after a rough few weeks to open the season out in center field.

Unfortunately for Rafaela, he’s up against some tough competition with his fellow outfielders. Bryan Buxton, Aaron Judge (who will need an injury replacement), Riley Greene, Mike Trout and Jac Caglianone all have great cases for being chosen to the game and Rafaela’s best shot may be (much like Contreras) being an injury replacement after the initial roster is announced.

Could Be Selected

This section is a bit different than the others. In here, there are two players who very well could be All-Stars but most likely won’t be due to one reason or another. The first being the Red Sox's big off-season acquisition, Ranger Suárez. Suárez has done everything the Red Sox have hoped for and then some. Through his first 16 starts he has a career low ERA (as a full-time starter) of 2.94 while tossing 88 2/3 quality innings. While Gray may very well be the current ace of the rotation, there is an argument to be made that it could be Suárez.

His metrics show that he’s been one of the best in all of baseball in limiting hard contact as his exit velocity on average is 86.4 mph and his hard-hit rate is just 31.5%. Add that to a career-high strikeout per nine innings of 9.3 and a WHIP of 1.128, and Suárez has looked absolutely nasty on the mound.

Unfortunately for Suárez, should Chapman and Gray both make the team, there won’t be much room for a third pitcher from the Red Sox as there are other quality arms around the American League that could be selected. Add to it that every team must have at least one representative and it starts to make the All-Star Game into a numbers game (much like actual roster construction around baseball).

One thing working in Suárez’s favor, however, has been his stellar month of June. In his five starts, the left-hander tossed 30 innings while allowing just seven earned runs, good for the fifth-best ERA in the American League at 2.10. Perhaps that earned him enough late momentum to get a nod.

The second and final member of this section would be none other than Payton Tolle. There’s no debate surrounding the skill of Tolle, since being promoted to Boston in mid-April the large left-hander has helped the rotation immensely with a 4-5 record in 13 starts. In those 13 outings, he’s thrown 74 1/3 innings with a strong 3.34 ERA to go along with 74 strikeouts.

The obvious argument against his case of being an All-Star is his time in the majors. He spent the beginning of April in the minors and hasn’t accumulated as much playing time as the others. But there’s one thing that can be used against that notion: Jacob Misiorowski. For those who may not know the full story, there was great debate at last year’s All-Star selections as Misiorowski was named as an injury replacement for the All-Star Game after just five career starts. Those who agreed with his selection argued that the All-Star Game should be a recognition of the best players and skills. And with Misiorowski, there’s no denying he has the best fastball in the National League.

It just so happens that Tolle has a great fastball too. Using the logic from last year, wouldn’t it be a similar case for Tolle to make it as an injury replacement just so fans can watch the 6-foot-6, 250-pound left-hander hurl fastballs that can peak around triple digits. For fans of the game, who wouldn’t want to see Tolle staring down some of the best the National League has to offer?

Unfortunately for Tolle, there just won’t be enough room for him this year. Let's all turn our gaze toward 2027 for his hopeful Midsummer Classic debut.