Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

Sonny Gray signing elsewhere was not entirely surprising, but the ease with which the Boston Red Sox let him walk is a major red flag. To rehash, Gray just led the Sox in innings pitched (169.0) by over 20, had the lowest ERA (2.72) of any of their starters, led the AL in wins and win percentage, finished fifth in Cy Young voting, and yet they still couldn’t be bothered to beat a two-year, $55 million contract from the Minnesota Twins. 

Look, I’m no dummy. I saw the decline in strikeouts, the uptick in contact rate, and the regression monster looming, but $55 million over two years is the cost of acquiring an above-average starter who can take the bump 28 times a season. Dustin May, who has a 4.82 ERA over the past two seasons and an injury list that looks like a game of Operation, just got $52.5 million over three seasons. If you believe Gray is too expensive, then you simply do not believe in signing quality free-agent pitchers.  

The Red Sox made the postseason in consecutive seasons for the first time since 2017-18 on the strength of their pitching. They finished third in the league in ERA (3.54), were first in FIP (3.65), and it helped them overcome mediocre performances from their position players. And having a stable of quality starters helped them weather injuries and ineffectiveness. So, while their 2027 staff looks great on paper, it raises far more questions than the 2026 iteration. 

Will Garrett Crochet have a healthy season? How will Payton Tolle and Jake Bennett hold up in their sophomore seasons? Ranger Suarez is a metronome of consistency, but that also means making under 30 starts. And a right-handed starter would be nice. The Red Sox's top four is excellent, but their fifth spot could be an issue, and should anyone miss an extended stretch, their minor-league reinforcements have been whittled down considerably. 

In the span of 24 months, the Sox have gone from incredible organizational pitching depth to needing at least 25 starts each from their projected Opening Day rotation. They traded Wikelman Gonzalez, Brandon Clarke, Richard Fitts, Blake Aita, Yhoiker Fajardo, Hunter Dobbins, Kyle Harrison, Shane Drohan, Connelly Early, Anthony Eyanson, and Kyson Witherspoon for Garrett Crochet, Sonny Gray, Wilson Contreras, Caleb Durbin, Curtis Mead, and Adley Rutschman. 

While this is by no means a comprehensive list, now that Gray has departed, the Sox functionally turned 11 pitching prospects into one 2027 starter. There obviously isn’t space in the rotation for all of Fitts, Dobbins, Harrison, Drohan, and Early, but they all would be solid fifth options and have all already pitched in the majors. Not to mention, Eyanson is one of the top pitching prospects in baseball.

The Red Sox have invested considerable prospect capital to build this team, and they’re an injury away from having to see if Brayan Bello can go from the worst starter in the league to tolerable. And all of this stems from the same place: the Red Sox have become a big-market franchise in name only. 

As of today, the Red Sox's 2027 payroll is projected to hit $282,811,667. If they maintain that figure into the season, it will be the highest in franchise history by over $50 million. So, even if they make a few cost-cutting moves, as reporting suggests they will, the 2027 team is guaranteed to blow by the franchise record of $229,166,880 payroll, set in 2019. 

The problem is that since the 2019 squad led baseball in payroll, the Sox have shed salary, while the rest of the league has added. 

Red Sox Payroll 2011 - 2026

Season

Payroll

Rk

League Ave.

Wins

Win %

Payroll +

2011

$170,490,761

2

$100,705,074

90

0.556

169.30

2012

$173,216,551

3

$106,819,802

69

0.426

162.16

2013

$170,734,264

3

$109,910,010

97

0.599

155.34

2014

$170,095,758

5

$119,933,151

71

0.438

141.83

2015

$183,481,478

3

$128,402,162

78

0.481

142.90

2016

$207,758,836

3

$134,039,907

93

0.574

155.00

2017

$209,902,508

2

$140,873,405

93

0.574

149.00

2018

$227,398,860

1

$139,299,327

108

0.667

163.24

2019

$229,166,880

1

$138,596,264

84

0.519

165.35

2020

$84,210,390

4

$61,692,067

24

0.400

136.50

2021

$187,100,784

6

$131,503,257

92

0.568

142.28

2022

$211,808,993

6

$150,556,869

78

0.481

140.68

2023

$182,930,664

13

$166,354,341

78

0.481

109.96

2024

$190,176,846

11

$170,337,880

81

0.500

111.65

2025

$197,058,856

12

$175,348,218

89

0.549

112.38

2026

$207,988,016

10

$181,695,264

87

0.537

114.47

Between 2011 and 2026, the league average payroll increased by 80.4%. If the Red Sox had kept pace with inflation since 2011, they’d have run a $307.5 million payroll in 2026. Instead, it came in at just shy of $208 million, a 21.9% increase from 2011. The clear line of demarcation from large-market club to upper-middle class is 2019. 

Between 2011 and 2019, the Sox’s average payroll rank was 2.56, with a Payroll+ of 155.67 (100 being average). Since then, their average payroll rank has slipped to 8.86 and their Payroll+ to 121.57, and it gets even worse post-2022.

The Red Sox curtailing spending from 2019 on, and in particular since 2022, wasn’t some grievous mistake. They did an excellent job restocking their farm system, which allowed them to build this current roster through internal promotions and trade. 

However, if building a cost-controlled, perpetual minor-league machine was their goal, then they shouldn’t have traded over half the farm to add impact major-league talent. But since they have, the mistake now would be not capitalizing on the fruits of that rebuild simply to save some money. 

The advantage of being a large-market franchise is that when your farm system produces a bumper crop, you can buy the finishing touches. And unless the Sox make a real splash in free agency, they appear content to shuffle the deck chairs and hope for the best, again. The post-2019 Red Sox have been in a perpetual identity crisis, where they can’t decide if they want to be the Brewers or the Dodgers, when they could be both.

To be clear, letting Gray walk specifically isn’t really the issue; rather, it’s a symptom of the Red Sox’s steady decline from a marquee franchise into mediocrity. The core of a championship team is right there, but they keep taking half measures. Sure, if you squeak into the playoffs, you can always get lucky, but that’s not supposed to be the type of franchise we're rooting for. They’re supposed to go for it, and that means putting your money where your mouth is.


View full article

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...