"Greatest Red Sox of All Time"

[who]

Based only off of career in a Sox uniform.

C: Carlton Fisk

1B: Jimmie Foxx

2B: Bobby Doerr

SS: Nomar Garciapparra (love him or hate him, he was a HOF before he left Boston)

3B: Wade Boggs

LF: Ted Williams, and its not close.

CF: Tris Speaker is the popular choice, but I go with Fred Lynn based on Boston years only.

RF: Dwight Evans

DH: David Ortiz

SP: Cy Young

SP: Pedro Martinez

SP: Roger Clemens

SP: Lefty Grove

SP: Babe Ruth

RP: Jonathan Papelbon

RP: Bob Stanley

RP: Dick Raditz

RP: Mike Timlin

 

Honorable Mention....Varitek, Vaughn, Pesky, Yaz, Rice, Ramirez, Speaker, Schilling, Dutch Leonard, Tiant, Smokey Joe Wood, Tom Gordon, Dennis Eckersley, Lee Smith

[Emmz]

Jarrod Saltalamacchia.

[who]

Jarrod Saltalamacchia.

 

Any day for the greatest hair of Redsox history, although he would have to battle against Pedros jheri curls.

[IRON HORSE]

In time, Ellsbury and Pedroia will be on this list. As for managers, I know I might get some rebuttal against this, but for best manager I would take Tito any day of the week. What does everyone else think?

[RedSoxfanforlife305]

Ellsbury? I don't think so.

[IRON HORSE]

What about the Yankee Killer, Josh Beckett? Love or hate him, he was our ace and played a monumental part in our '07 World Series championship

[RedSoxNC84]

What about the Yankee Killer, Josh Beckett? Love or hate him, he was our ace and played a monumental part in our '07 World Series championship

 

Beckett is mid-tier. He helped get the Sox 07, but that's about it.

[Bellhorn04]

Beckett's place is on the list of 'Greatest Seasons by a Red Sox'. He's on the short list for pitchers.